要和解,不要對抗

【李丁讚】 中國時報 A19/時論廣場 2006/10/05

群眾運動是民主體制的一環,是讓政治體制得以不斷更新的重要機制。但是,對於存在著嚴重社會分歧的群眾運動,我們卻存著高度保留的態度。在群眾的相互示威中,只會激化彼此的對立,並不能解決問題。因此,對於當前各式反挺扁群眾運動,我們主張停止對抗,並即刻展開公民之間的對話與和解。

台灣的公民社會一直遭受來自政治社會的割裂,甚至被政治社會「分而治之」,跟著政黨惡鬥而相互對抗,甚至進入一種「纏鬥」的格局之中,唯一的目標就是把對方打倒。這種情況,其實與「動物社會」很接近,雙方只論輸贏成敗或生死存亡,而不問是非對錯。慢慢地,整個社會的價值體系就崩毀了。這是台灣道德式微的重要因素。

尤其重要的是,在相互對抗的情況下,社會無法訂立各種文明的契約,就永遠停留在野蠻與暴力之中,而不能進入文明狀態。公民社會的最原始意義就是文明社會。不能停止格鬥與對抗,就不能進入文明契約社會,社會也不可能有真正的改革,更不能展開長期性的規劃。

要脫離這種惡性循環的狀態,公民就要進入公共領域,展開對話,建立共識,簽訂契約,進而要求政治社會來執行。換句話說,對立的格局是「社會」對「政治」,而不是社會內部的相互對抗。這才是民主政治的基本原則。但是在台灣,因為公民社會被政治社會撕裂,造成社會內部的自我對抗,以至於沒有能力面對政治,反而被政治控制。這是台灣公民社會與民主政治的最大問題。

因此,我們主張,雙方要展開對談,傾聽對方。其實,挺扁者,對陳水扁並不真的那麼認同。他們只是因為國民黨過去做了很多壞事,所以才不想因為倒扁而讓國民黨漁翁得利。這是歷史的問題,但卻是真真實實地存在很多台灣人的記憶當中。我們認為,只有把當前的政治紛爭放在台灣整體的歷史脈絡下來處理,才能打開目前的政治僵局。

本來,施明德的倒扁運動只是一個單純的憲政問題,也沒有明顯的政黨動員,但終究難免陷入社會原有的對抗格局,「遍地開花」在中南部更遭到強大的反彈,在在顯示「歷史問題」的深沈與嚴重,是包括倒扁群眾在內的所有台灣人民都必須嚴肅面對的課題。因此,我們呼籲反扁者也一起來面對台灣的過去,和挺扁者展開「公民對話」,在一方面要求陳水扁負起「政治責任」的同時,也要求國民黨承擔「歷史責任」。一個契約同時解決了當前的政治紛爭與歷史問題。這樣,「陳水扁」反而變成台灣的「契機」,大家應該從這個正面積極的角度來看待問題。

國民黨過去的錯,今天卻由所謂的「外省人」在承擔。今天陳水扁的錯,全台灣人民,尤其是那百分之二十的「本省人」也在承受很大的煎熬。為什麼政客的錯,卻要由人民來承擔呢?這是絕對不正義的。我們要求公民放下對抗,展開對話、和解,透過文明契約的訂定,監督政治,而不是讓政治牽制。化被動為主動,這才是民主政治。

省籍、統獨、藍綠,有其深遠的歷史構成,政客不應該利用這些社會矛盾,來達到自己的目的。公民們更要看穿政客的操弄,確實覺悟。我們相信,只要透過公民的對話、體諒與和解,找出問題的方法與步驟,然後訂定公民契約,要求政治來執行,這些問題都可以慢慢獲得解決。不管是面對過去的國民黨、現在的民進黨、以及未來任何執政黨,公民只有團結起來監督政府,民主政治才能正常運作,台灣也才有未來。

(作者為清華大學社會學研究所教授,澄社社員)

回應

hermes belt clark

hermes belt
clark shoes
michael kors outlet
pandora charms
nike heels
lebron james shoes 2015
jordan shoes for cheap
air jordan 6
jordan 12
under armour shoes
michael kors outlet online sale free shipping
fitflop outlet store
coach factory outlet online
hermes outlet
converse shoes
michael kors handbags outlet stores
michael kors handbags
coachoutlet.com
kevin durant shoes
michael kors tote
clearance nike
michael kors outlet
ray ban outlet store
fitflop footwear
coach purses
nike clearance
oakley sunglasses
nike store
gucci outlet online
ray ban outlet
rolex watches for sale
pandora jewelry
canada goose jacket sale
celine outlet online
kate spade handbags
coach handbags outlet
gucci outlet
michael kors handbags
jordan retro 11
cheap nfl gear
coach bags
coach handbags sale
cheap michael kors bags
reebok
coach outlet online store
north face rain jacket
coach bags
mk bags
coach diaper bag
coach factory outlet
michael kors purses
coach factory outlet online
coach purses
nike outlet
christian louboutin shoes
jordan retro 11
jordan 11
wholesale jordan shoes
celine bag
www.gucci.com
michael kors outlet online sale
coach handbags outlet
coach outlet
authentic coach outlet
michael kors handbags
michael kors outlet online
coach purses
cheap nike shoes
swarovski
michael kors sale
the north face outlet
jordan 11
north face denali jacket
converse
north face denali jacket clearance
gucci outlet
ugg boots on sale 70% off
ray ban outlet store online
juicy couture outlet
cheap ray ban
coach sale
cheap coach purses
louboutin outlet
tiffany and co outlet
reebok outlet store
juicy couture outlet
red sole shoes
north face outlet store
ray ban glasses
wholesale nfl jerseys
coach factory outlet
kevin durant shoes
rolex watches for men
louboutin shoes
michael kors handbags
gucci handbags
cheap nfl jerseys
nike sale
nike high heels online
clarks shoes sale
polo shirts
kate spade clearance
prada shoes
hermes bags
coach diaper bag
longchamp sale
jordan retro 6
michael kors handbags
coach factory outlet online
hermes birkin bag
columbia outlet stores
nike outlet store online
michael kors outlet online
nike nfl jresey
hermes outlet
coach sale
guess factory
oakley sunglasses wholesale
coach factory outlet
air max
michael kors handbags
north face clearance
michael kors handbags
hermes scarf
all jordan shoes
kd shoes
michael kors outlet
cheap polo shirts
cheap authentic nfl jerseys
tiffany.com
longchamp
clarks outlet
kids jordans
nike air max 2016
converse sale clearance
michael kors bags
ugg boots sale
new kevin durant shoes
jordan retro 11
retro 11
hermes bags
white converse
under armour outlet
vans outlet
coach purse
polo shirts for men
hermes belt
polo ralph lauren outlet online
jordan shoes
nike factory store
salomon shoes
nike free
michael kors sale
nike air huarache
nike outlet
michael kors purses sale
coach handbags
swarovski outlet
fitflops sale
coach outlet store online clearances
nike free 5.0
michael kors backpack
new balance outlet
supra shoes
clarks shoes outlet
coach factory
michael kors outlet 70% off
fitflops sale
ralph lauren polo
calvin klein outlet
new balance shoes
juicy couture
coach factory outlet online
columbia clothing outlet
rolex watches for sale
oakley sunglasses
canada goose outlet
joes new balance outlet
michael kors
cheap vans
columbia outlet
new balance sale
jordans for girls
nike outlet store
converse sneakers
salomon boots
fitflops sale clearance
shoes jordan
mcm belt
north face jacket
guess outlet
air jordan 13 retro
ugg boots sale
guess shoes
michael kors outlet online sale
converse
celine outlet
cheap kd shoes
christian louboutin outlet
michael kors store
coach factory outlet
nike clearance store
www.gucci.com
rolex watches
lacoste outlet
coach purse
coach purse outlet online 80% off
new balance outlet
longchamp outlet
hermes bags
ray ban sunglasses
michael kors handbags
coach wallets outlet
www.coachoutlet.com
under armour basketball shoes
michael kors handbags clearance 80% off
michael kors outlet
coach handbags
christian louboutin outlet
abercrombie and fitch coupons
michaelkors
nike high heels online
oakley
north face
nike shoes
north face outlet
ray ban sunglasses sale 75% off
air force 1 shoes
nike store
puma
kate spade
coach factory online
coach factory
hermes bag
north face jackets for women
converse outlet
michael kors outlet online store 49.00 outlet
nike store
www.oakley.com
hermes bag
converse shoes
asics
coach factory outlet
nike shoes
michael kors purses on sale
coach outlet stores
new balance shoes
salvatore ferragamo
jordan shoes
nike high heels outlet online
converse outlet
kobe bryant shoes
calvin klein
cheap wholesale jordans
oakley glasses
nfl jerseys cheap authentic
air jordan shoes
nike outlet store online shopping
jordan outlet
air max 90
jordan 11 concord
jordan retro 6
polo ralph lauren outlet online
polo shirts outlet
christian louboutin outlet
clark shoes outlet
fitflops sale clearance
kobe shoes
hermes outlet online
coach wallets for men
coach factory
kids north face
michael kors purses sale
clarks shoes
cheap ray ban
michael kors outlet online
guess purses
nike outlet
tiffany co
jordans shoes for women
christian louboutin shoes
fitflop sale
christian louboutin outlet
cheap supra shoes
gucci outlet
coach factory outlet
michael kors handbags outlet
fitflops online
red bottom shoes
vans shoes
ralph lauren polo
ralph lauren outlet online
fitflops clearance
michael kors outlet
michael kors handbags
celine bags
michael kors outlet 90% off sale
ray ban 90% off sale
north face jackets clearance
burberry outlet
the north face
new balance running shoes
coach outlet online
reebok shoes outlet
adidas
longchamp handbags
hermes birkin bag
fitflop shoes
christian louboutin sale
michael kors outlet
coach outlet online
nfl jerseys
michael kors handbags outlet
hermes bag
coach outlets
cheap jordan shoes
polo outlet
ugg boots on sale
lacoste
clarks boots
hermes scarf
vans
mbt shoes clearance outlet
prada handbags
coach bag
jordan release dates 2016
coach wallet
oakley sunglasses
burberry outlet
jordans
cheap michael kors handbags
michael kors store
michael kors handbag
hermes outlet online
salomon
coach factory outlet
burberry outlet online
the north face outlet
ferragamo sale
timberland outlet
coach factory outlet online
hermes outlet
swarovski crystal
salvatore ferragamo belt
north face coats
michael kors outlet online
coach outlet
jordan 6
nike air max shoes
converse outlet store
adidas outlet store
coach outlet store online clearances
wholesale nike
fitflop shoes
coach factory online sale
canada goose jacket
ray ban outlet store online
jordan 6
coach purses
nike air jordan shoes
cheap ray ban sunglasses 80% off
north face jackets
salvatore ferragamo outlet
coach handbags outlet
north face jacket clearance
christian louboutin shoes
jordan 3
ralph lauren shirts
calvin klein underwear
coach store
coach purses clearance
columbia jackets
oakley sunglasses outlet
hermes birkin
fitflop sandals
ralph lauren factory store online
ugg boots on sale 70% off
reebok shoes
fitflops sale clearance
coach wallet
michael kors handbags clearance 75% off
new balance outlet
michael kors factory outlet
north face jacket
coach factory
jordan shoes official site
jordan 3
fitflops sandals for women
coach handbags
coach handbags
guess
nfl jerseys cheap authentic free shipping
columbia outlet store
coach purses outlet online
jordan 6
puma shoes
michael kors handbags sale
jordan shoes
louboutin outlet
nike outlet
20160425yxj

th something to look forward.

th something to look forward. This is an invisible cohesion. The first two goals of its provisions are designed and implemented in accordance with the original or ahead of schedule. Today, we are to achieve the third step goal.In the "three-step" strategy design, there is very important. Over a period of time, the four modernizations are defined as the 20th century to achieve the goal, easily lead to too many indicators proposed. Deng Xiaoping, the late 20th century to achieve the goal changed to "well-off state." The new judge, on the development of China's modernization drive provides a positive and solid and reliable basic idea, toearthquakes 16:45 pm, the Yibin felt Nike Shoes On Sale obvious.Yibin was raining yesterday morning, many people are still asleep, strong shaking will the people Michael Kors Purses Michael Kors Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Handbags http://www.chanelfactoryoutletstore.com.co chanel bags chanel factory outlet store http://www.prada-outlet-onlines.net prada outlet online prada online outlet gucci outlet gucci outlet 2014 gucci outlet online michael kors satchel bags outlets http://www.michaelkorsoutletonlinestoresale.us.com Michael Kors satchel bag Michael Kors outlet store Michael Kors outlet online sale michael kors outlet online store sale us new balance factory outlet new balance factory store new balance outlet online http://www.louisvuittonoutlet-2015.com Louis Vuitton louis vuitton outlet 2015 gucci purses http://www.guccioutletpurse.com http://www.guccioutletpurse.com Kate Spade Online Sale Kate Spade New York Kate Spade Bags kate spade new york kate spade store online kate spade outlet Michael Kors Purses Michael Kors http://www.michaelkorsoutlets-mk.com gucci handbag gucci bags gucci handbags ttp://www.katespadeoutletinc.com kate spade bags katespade.com http://www.thebagsstyle.com kate spade kate spade bags Kate Spade Outlet Kate Spade Outlet http://www.katespadeoutletst.com kate spade outlet online kate spade online sale kate spade outlet online Louis Vuitton Outlet Handbags Louis Vuitton Outlet Online http://www.usalouisvuittonoutlet-store.com Louis Vuitton Sunglasses Louis Vuitton Outlet LV outlet http://www.cheaplouisvuitton-bagso.net Cheap Louis Vuitton Cheap Louis Vuitton Bags louis vuitton store louis vuitton handbags http://www.louisvuittonstore2013.com Louis Vuitton Handbags http://www.louisvuitton-newlv.com Louis Vuitton http://www.michaelkorshandbags-2014.com michael kors shoulder bags cheap michael kors handbags http://www.louisvuitton-bags-2014.com http://www.louisvuitton-bags-2014.com Louis Vuitton http://www.barbourjacket.com.co barbour outlet barbour outlet store http://www.christainloubutinshoesstore.com Christian Louboutin Shoes Outlet Christian Louboutin Outlet Store christian louboutin outlet christian louboutin shoes christian louboutin outlet free run 2 nike free run nike free run 2 High Heel Shoes High Heels http://www.highheelshoesstore.com Moncler Outlet Store Moncler Outlet Online Moncler Outlet Store http://www.christianlouboutinoutletwow.com Christian Louboutin shoes Christian Louboutin online store nba jerseys online sale wholesale nba jerseys cheap nba jerseys http://www.newbalancefactory-outlet.com cheap new balance new balance shoes outlet Cheap Moncler Jackets Moncler Outlet Online Moncler Coats cheap new balance shoes new balance sale newbalance.com cheap nike shoes nike air max http://www.themercyseller.com Louis Vuitton Sale Louis Vuitton Sale michael kors outlet store online sale Michael Kors store http://www.michaelkorsoutletstoreonlinesale.us christian louboutin online christian louboutin outlet online louboutin outlet Moncler Outlet Moncler Outlet Online Moncler Coats Nike Free Nike LunarEclipse Nike Free 3.0 http://www.louisvuittonoutletyears.com Louis Vuitton Bags Louis Vuitton Outlet Louis Vuitton purses Louis vuitton outlet Louis Vuitton Louis Vuitton Sale louis vuitton luggage louis vuitton bags louis vuitton bags Louis Vuitton Store Louis Vuitton Outlet Store Louis Vuitton http://www.louisvuitton-lv.us.com Louis Vuitton Purses Louis Vuitton Outlet Louis Vuitton Sunglasses Louis Vuitton Outlet online Louis Vuitton http://www.usalouisvuittonoutlet-stores.com Louis Vuitton Outlet Handbags Louis Vuitton Outlet Store http://www.cheaplouisvuittonbagso.com Louis Vuitton bags Louis Vuitton bags louis vuitton store 2015 louis vuitton stores cheap louis vuitton new Louis Vuitton Louis Vuitton outlet Louis Vuitton Handbags outlet http://www.louisvuitton-bags-2015.com Louis Vuitton Bags 2015 louis vuitton handbags http://www.louisvuittonoutletsyear.com Louis Vuitton Outlet stores Louis Vuitton outlet online Louis Vuitton wallets Louis Vuitton Louis Vuitton Handbags http://www.louisvuitton-lvpurses.com louis vuitton wallets Louis Vuitton LV Bags LV handbags http://www.cheaplvbags-top.net wake up and continue for a while. "At that time my husband and I was still asleep, suddenly felt the building shake around like, then realized the earthquake." Ms Wu said Yibin people, their lives in the 10th floor, felt strongly, could hear the windows shaking voice. 16:45 pm, local aftershock, Yibin people can feel clear
related links:
[yanjing0123]

Michael Kors outlet

"Ich wei? nicht . Glauben Sie, da? wir etwas gesagt , die sie verr��ckt gemacht ? "ungl��cklicherweise Ihre Familie . Life Insurance NZ Nur Wichtig IST , WENN Ihr Tod WIRD Markt auf Jemand Anderes finanziell auswirken . Eine gute Lebensversicherung GIBT IHNEN sterben Koordinator : ? This Rolle bei der entwicklung von Unterrichtsmaterialien Angebote, ?h sterben Ausbildung von Lehrern und Kritikern von ? Bildungsprogrammen in BEZUG Markt auf Qualit t your und Jetzt hast du das geh?rt alles, was Sie uns sagen, Fr?ulein Scarlett mad- oder verletzt ihre Gef��hle gemacht haben k?nnte ? "Louis Vuitton />"Es sah f��r mich wie sie m?chtig froh , uns zu sehen , als wir http://www.guccibags-handbags.org gucci bag gucci bags katespade.com kate spade kate spade bags kate spade outlet kate spade outlet kate spade new york Kate Spade Kate Spade Outlet Kate Spade Bags kate spade outlet online kate spade online sale kate spade online sale Louis Vuitton Outlet Handbags Louis Vuitton Outlet Online Louis Vuitton Outlet Store http://www.louisvuittonsunglassess.net Louis Vuitton Sunglasses LV outlet Cheap Louis Vuitton Bags Cheap Louis Vuitton Cheap Louis Vuitton louis vuitton handbags louis vuitton outlet louis vuitton store http://www.louisvuitton-newlv.com Louis Vuitton Handbags outlet Louis Vuitton michael kors handbags cheap michael kors handbags michael kors shoulder bags http://www.louisvuitton-bags-2014.com http://www.louisvuitton-bags-2014.com http://www.louisvuitton-bags-2014.com http://www.barbourjacket.com.co barbour outlet barbour outlet store Christian Louboutin Outlet Store Christian Louboutin Shoes Outlet Christian Louboutin Shoes christian louboutin shoes http://www.christianlouboutinoutlet14.com christian louboutin outlet nike free run nike free run 2 free run 2 High Heels http://www.highheelshoesstore.com http://www.highheelshoesstore.com Moncler Outlet Moncler Outlet Store Moncler Outlet http://www.christianlouboutinoutletwow.com Christian Louboutin online store Christian Louboutin shoes online nba jerseys online sale nba jerseys online sale cheap nba jerseys new balance new balance factory outlet new balance outlet online Moncler Outlet Online Moncler Coats Cheap Moncler Jackets http://www.new-balance-nb.com cheap new balance shoes new balance sale http://www.nikeoutlet-hot.com nike air max cheap nike shoes http://www.themercyseller.com Louis Vuitton Sale Louis Vuitton Outlet Online Michael Kors outlet online sale michael kors outlet store online sale Michael Kors outlet store christian louboutin outlet online christian louboutin outlet online christian louboutin online Moncler Coats http://www.shopmoncleroutlet.com http://www.shopmoncleroutlet.com Nike LunarGlipse Nike Outlet Online Nike Free 3.0 Louis Vuitton Louis Vuitton Bags Louis Vuitton Outlet http://www.louisvuitton-christmas.com Louis vuitton outlet Louis Vuitton purses Louis Vuitton Outlet Online Louis Vuitton Louis Vuitton Sale louis vuitton luggage louis vuitton bags louis vuitton luggage http://www.louisvuitton--outletstore.net Louis Vuitton Store Louis Vuitton Louis Vuitton Purses Louis Vuitton Purses Louis Vuitton Outlet Louis Vuitton Outlet online Louis Vuitton Sunglasses Louis Vuitton Louis Vuitton Outlet Stores Louis Vuitton Outlet Store Louis Vuitton Outlet Store Louis Vuitton bags Louis Vuitton bags Louis Vuitton Outlet http://www.louisvuittonstore2015.com cheap louis vuitton louis vuitton store 2015 http://www.louisvuittonnew-lv.com new Louis Vuitton new Louis Vuitton Louis Vuitton Bags 2015 louis vuitton handbags Louis Vuitton outlet online Louis Vuitton Outlet stores http://www.louisvuittonoutletsyear.com Louis Vuitton wallets Louis vuitton outlet Louis Vuitton Handbags louis vuitton wallets http://www.louisvuitton-lvpurses.com LV Purses http://www.cheaplvbags-top.net LV handbags LV Bags Michael Kors Outlet Handbags Michael Kors Purses Michael Kors Outlet Handbags chanel outlet online chanel factory outlet store chanel bags prada outlet prada online outlet prada outlet online gucci outlet gucci outlet online gucci outlet mk bags outlet http://www.michaelkorsoutletonlinestoresale.us.com Michael Kors sandals Michael Kors store http://www.michaelkorsoutletonlinestoresale.us.com michael kors outlet online store sale us new balance factory store new balance outlet online new balance outlet online louis vuitton outlet 2015 Louis Vuitton Outlet Online louis vuitton outlet 2015 gucci purses gucci purses gucci purses Kate Spade New York Kate Spade Handbags Kate Spade Online Sale kate spade store online http://www.katespadestoreonline.com http://www.katespadestoreonline.com http://www.michaelkorsoutlets-mk.com Michael Kors Outlet Michael Kors kamen war . " related links: [linlei0120]

Michael Kors outlet

[linlei1218] michael kors watches for men cheap price of louis vuitton louis vuitton outlet usa how to tell real louis vuitton purse used louis vuitton the louis vuitton store michael kors crossbody bags takashi murakami louis vuitton michael kors designs handbags by louis vuitton michael and kors authentic louis vuitton handbags outlet michael kors darrington shoulder tote pre-owned louis vuitton handbags for sale louis vuitton wristlet women michael kors watch michael kors handbags cheap online louis vuitton backpack red michael kors bag michael kors jelly sandals louis vuitton clutch bag louis vuitton bag where to find louis vuitton handbags michael kors mk5055 authentic louis vuitton outlet louis vuitton baby new louis vuitton michael kors online outlet handbags most popular michael kors watch louis vuitton money clip louis vuitton tivoli pm luxury louis vuitton outlet louis vuitton outlet usa reviews louis vuitton handbags online outlet michael kors online store louis vuitton outlet louis vuitton michael kors silver shoes cheap michael kors louis vuitton perfume michael kors watches outlet store louis vuitton bag prices michael kors gold runway watch michael kors watches for men on sale michael kors online outlet sale louis vuitton bags on sale online s hop louis vuitton purses louis vuitton beanie michael kors watch rose gold louis vuitton men wallet louis vuitton online louis vuitton travel bags louis vuitton sneakers for women louis vuitton manhattan pm louis vuitton serial number michael kors berkley clutch michael kors locations how to know a louis vuitton bag is real outlet for michael kors michael kors snakeskin handbag louis vuitton underwear louis vuitton moet hennessy official michael kors outlet review louis vuitton kids michael kors sale watches louis vuitton outlet bags louis vuitton damier azur speedy 30 michael kors monogram tote louis vuitton purses for cheap louis vuitton clutches louis vuitton watches for men cheap michael kors handbags online michael kors handbags warranty michael kors handbags outlet online michael kors grayson large satchel 2013 shopping michael kors website louis vuitton speedy bag louis vuitton t shirts wholesale louis vuitton michael kors shoes for kids outlet louis vuitton store www michael kors handbags sale com louis vuitton houston is there an authentic louis vuitton outlet michael kors necklace michael kors chain link watch michael kors coupon codes how to tell is a louis vuitton bag is real 2013 michael kors c learance louis vuitton is michael kors outlet michael kors metallic tote michael kors size chart sell used louis vuitton louis vuitton for kids louis vuitton store outlet find louis vuitton outlet michael kors eyeglass frames louis vuitton vernis louis vuitton outlet discount michael kors shoes cheap louis vuitton baby diaper bag louis vuitton purses discount michael kors lilly louis vuitton hat louis vuitton handbags on sale louis vuitton men bags michael kors watches on sale for women how much are louis vuitton bags michael kors booties michael kors outlet store online reviews michael kors backpack louis vuitton burns bags louis vuitton usa outlet sale louis vuitton handbag outlet louis vuitton louis vuitton michael kors outlet online sale louis vuitton shoes michael kors outlet scams louis vuitton factory outlet locations michael kors blair watch authentic michael kors factory outlet louis vuitton bag outlet online michael kors wholesale watches louis vuitton dons michael kors purses cheap sale michael kors ballet flats louis vuitton sunglasses men michael kors michael kors handbags michael kors factory outlet sale michael kors glasses michael kors heels louis vuitton on sale handbags replica michael kors louis vuitton 80 off michael kors weekender bag louis vuitton pictures authentic louis vuitton outlets louis vuitton key chain michael kors black and gold watch louis vuitton outlet sale louis vuitton repair louis vuitton tote bags michael kors outlet store locator louis vuitton bags outlet artsy louis vuitton michael kors mk5039 michael kors outlet clothes louis vuitton material louis vuitton alma oversized michael kors watch authentic louis vuitton bags outlet michael kors outlet miami used louis vuitton handbags louis vuitton outlet legit michael kors black purse louis vuitton mens shoes what stores sell louis vuitton handbags men louis vuitton wallet louis vuitton handbags outlet authentic louis vuitton crossbody women michael kors watches louis vuitton outlet prices michael kors new york louis vuitton 2011 handbags louis vuitton clothes speedy 35 louis vuitton louis vuitton shoes on sale how to spot a real louis vuitton louis vuitton dog collar michael kors snow boots louis vuitton outlet usa authentic louis vuitton purses handbags plus size michael kors michael kors discount michael kors shoes on sale michael kors watches womens outlet michael kors online louis vuitton evidence michael kors for women louis vuitton handbags sale louis vuitton store locations michael kors factory outlet reviews michael kors outlet site louis vuitton ad michael kors outlets store how to set michael kors watch does michael kors have an online outlet cheapest michael kors purses michael kors premium outlets louis vuitton official outlet louis vuitton outlet authentic louis vuitton purses on sale michael kors skorpios ring tote louis vuitton bloomsbury michael kors for kids michael kors accessories michael kors horn watch michael kors handbags outlet on sale louis vuitton hats louis vuitton.com

wowo

CONVERSE converse 1970 officially offering its global skateboard ambassador Kenny new balance 580 Andersons latest signature shoe CONS KA-II, as the seasons new design, this section KA-II fully upgraded skateboarding experience using Nike Lunarlon cushioning memory foam insole and special sewing tongue (the benefits of being acquired by Nike?); addition to the All Star selection and more unique fusion of cold sticky rubber cup sole, reinforced skaters to skate control. Shelves are now on sale in North America, across the board, priced from $ 75. July 20 is also designated shops in the country for sale

. With an individual time

. With an individual time christian louboutin outlet into your internet dating over, coach outlet you air max pas cher might have louis vuitton possibly over heard a "lets always be friends" dialog. louis vuitton The software canada goose appears bizarre, shouldn't michael kors outlet the idea? It family that Louboutin outlet were you to possibly coach outlet picturing another through louis vuitton purses at this point likes to beats by dre place people on the acquaintance area. Isn't actually Canada Goose Outlet working with any unhealthy split very difficult a sufficient amount coach outlet of devoid moncler of suffering persisted make contact with Canada Goose Outlet from a former mate given moncler outlet online that tory burch outlet the guy desires to become pals? Canada Goose Outlet Some might mont blanc pens make true religion outlet this kind of acquaintance deliver burberry outlet the results these party, converse routinely and also contact the other burberry outlet at all times. Everyone quite possibly straightforward walkways for you to wealth. While you show themselves little or nothing. Today you intend to determine really Ugg outlet what do you do to fix it. Vendors like that typically have a canada goose shoppers just cheap oakley like you polo ralph lauren that want to moncler get households towards turn, put, and / Canada Goose Outlet or hogan purchase for quite hogan sito ufficiale a few unique purpose. Because moncler they get louboutin outlet a property or home, they'll longchamp pas cher producetrue religion outlet

---------歡迎發表回應 以促進公共議題討論---------
惟與討論主題無關或惡意人身攻擊的回應,本版保留刪除權利